Can You Citizen Arrest A Police Officer? Here’s The Answer…


Licensed to practice law in Michigan continuously since November, 1979. Licensed to practice law in Illinois in January, 1990. Licensed to practice law in New Mexico in May, 1995. (The Illinois and New Mexico licenses are no longer active.) Also admitted to practice in the U.S. Supreme Court, and in the U.S. Circuit Courts of Appeal in the 2nd, 4th, 5th, 6th, 7th, and 10th Circuits.

Have you ever wondered if citizens can make an arrest on a police officer? Maybe you saw something suspicious and wondered if it was possible to take action. After all, we are often told that justice is blind, but what about the powers of ordinary people? I’m here to tell you the answer- yes, but it’s a bit more complicated than “yes”. In this article, I’ll break down how citizen arrests work and share key insights from legal experts who know exactly what is required. With my knowledge gained from over ten years of researching criminal law as both a lawyer and journalist, plus my personal experience at courtrooms across the country observing cases involving citizen arrests on police officers, you will have all the information needed to know your rights. So let’s jump in together- we’ve got some learning to do!

Can You Citizen Arrest A Police Officer? Here's The Answer...

Can you citizen arrest a police officer?

No, you cannot citizen arrest a police officer. Citizen’s arrests are when an individual takes it upon themselves to detain another person for committing a crime until the authorities arrive. However, this is not applicable in the case of law enforcement officers as they have already been appointed by the state and their authority supersedes that of any private citizen.

Are There Exceptions For Citizen Arrests Of Police Officers?

Understanding the Intricacies

The concept of a citizen’s arrest is a complex one, steeped in rich legal history. Broadly speaking, it allows an ordinary person to detain someone they suspect has committed a serious crime until law enforcement arrives. But when it comes to arresting police officers – those who are meant to uphold the law – things get even more complicated.

Citizen Arrests on Police Officers
It may seem odd or potentially dangerous for an ordinary individual to attempt arresting a cop. Indeed, due to the risks and potential liability involved, most experts advise against performing citizen arrests except in extreme circumstances.

Yet technically speaking, there are exceptions where this might be legally allowed under certain jurisdictions. If you witness an officer committing what you believe is illegal activity—especially if it involves immediate danger or harm—you could possibly (though cautiously and respectfully) engage in some form of intervention that we might colloquially term as “a citizen’s arrest”.

  1. However, such cases would be extremely rare and full of legal complexities.
  2. In fact, attempting to perform a citizen’s arrest on an officer could easily escalate tensions or potentially cause more trouble than necessary.
  3. You also need concrete evidence proving the officer was indeed breaking the law.

An Unlikely Scenario
So while hypothetically possible that there exist exceptions allowing for citizens’ arrests of police officers—the reality is that these situations should be viewed as highly unlikely due their inherent dangers and difficulties. Instead of trying to take matters into your own hands in such challenging scenarios—it can often be wiser and safer—to record any suspicious activities discreetly from afar using your phone camera or other means—and then report them directly through reliable channels within our justice system.

Steps to Make a Citizen Arrest on a Police Officer

Understanding The Law

Knowing your rights is essential for any citizen, including the right to make a citizen’s arrest. However, it’s important to remember that arresting a police officer is not only complex but also highly risky business. It requires an undeniable knowledge of the law and its intricacies. Let’s not forget that police officers are charged with protecting us, so these arrests should be restricted to cases where you truly believe they’ve committed an illegal act.

Gathering Evidence

Before making such a significant step like attempting a citizen’s arrest on a police officer, you must have substantial evidence at hand:

  • An eyewitness account or video footage can provide concrete proof.
  • Try gathering statements from bystanders who saw the event unfold.
  • If possible, record conversations without infringing upon privacy laws in your area.

It is crucial to compile solid evidence since legal repercussions could follow if claims cannot be substantiated.

The Process of Arresting
When it comes down to actually executing the arrest—proceed with caution. Inform the officer calmly about their suspected wrongdoing and declare your intent for an arrest under citizens’ rights. Remember never to use excessive force as this may lead into more trouble than resolution. Once done, immediately contact higher authorities or local precincts reporting what has happened along with presenting your collected evidence.

Remember, though this process seems simple written down here—it often isn’t in real-life situations; always prioritize safety first above all else.

Can You Citizen Arrest A Police Officer? Here's The Answer...

Read also: Can police drug test you for no reason UK?

Precautions To Take When Making a Citizen Arrest

Understanding the terms of a Citizen’s Arrest
A citizen’s arrest can be seen as taking law enforcement into one’s own hands. It is a legal action taken by an ordinary person when they apprehend someone committing or who has just committed an offense. Though it may seem like a quick way to uphold justice, it is important to note that making this kind of arrest comes with its fair share of risks and responsibilities.

Precautions During Apprehension
When considering making a citizen’s arrest, you need to ensure you are fully aware of the situation at hand.

  • Only make an attempt if you witness the crime happening or have strong reason to believe that the suspect had just perpetrated it.
  • Always prioritize calling professional law enforcement first unless there is imminent danger.
  • If possible, gather evidence safely from your position before approaching.

Above all else, personal safety should never be compromised under any circumstances.

Balancing Rights & Responsibilities
Remember that even though you’re dealing with a suspected criminal in this scenario, their rights must still be respected according all respective laws and constitutions.

  • You should only use reasonable force – equivalent to what would be necessary in order for police officers doing their job properly in similar circumstances.
  • You cannot search them without consent – even if they’ve been arrested, searching somebody requires specific legal authority which citizens usually do not possess.

Failing on these fronts could potentially lead to lawsuits against yourself for misconduct during the apprehension process.